|
The Cider House Rules (7-Sep-1999)
Director: Lasse Hallstrom Writer: John Irving From novel: Cider House Rules by John Irving Keywords: Drama, Coming of Age, Abortion A young man at a Maine orphanage is groomed as a doctor and abortionist to succeed the institution's director, Dr. Larch; instead Homer chooses his own course in life, finding menial employment at a farm's cider house while the farmer, a soldier, is off at war. Won Oscars for Best Supporting Actor and Best Adaptation; received additional nominations for Best Picture, Best Director, Best Original Score, Best Set Decoration and Best Editing.
REVIEWS Review by Walter Frith (posted on 9-Jun-2007) Orphans. How they are often forgotten. Having known a couple growing up, I won't
pretend to know what it feels like to be one, but some of their stories
are unforgettable. 'The Cider House Rules' takes a look at the orphan's
way of life, from a positive and very sensitive point of view and
stretches its story to include the adventures of one who is now a man,
setting off to experience the world for himself. Tobey Maguire
('Pleasantville'), is Homer Wells, a young man working at an orphanage
(and abortion clinic) in Maine during World War II and is loved by all
who live and work there. Homer is a right hand man to Dr. Wilbur Larch
(Michael Caine...playing with an American accent in his finest work in
years which will bring him an Oscar nomination). Dr. Larch sees Homer
as the one who will carry on his work at the orphanage when he leaves.
Community bureaucrats want Larch relieved of his position. Some critics
are making this film a political issue by saying that it is really
about abortion at its deepest roots but this argument doesn't wash.
Abortions are only a part of the story to wash away the false notion
that they didn't occur 50 or 60 years ago. It's like a gangster film.
The main plot is about crime. You don't look at a gangster film as
being a study of guns! Dr. Larch comforts the boys each night as they
get tucked in and as he turns off the light and closes the door to the
room, he says: "Good night, you princes of Maine, you kings of New
England!" Homer desires to leave the orphanage and see the world for
himself. He is tempted by Candy Kendall (Charlize Theron) and her
boyfriend Walter (Paul Rudd). They arrive one day at the orphanage
clinic to have an abortion and Homer decides to go off with them and
experience the free side of life. Homer says that he's never seen the
ocean and gets a chance to look at it. He also takes up a job picking
apples at Walter's family owned farm and befriends Mr. Rose (Delroy
Lindo) and his daughter Rose Rose (Erykah Badu). After going off to
fight in the war, Walter leaves Candy behind and she and Homer have an
affair. Meanwhile, the story shifts back and fourth at times to the
adventures of Homer's strengthening as a man and the events taking
place at the orphanage. One of the things most unexpected but welcomed
as a piece of exceptional drama, are the scenes which take place at the
farm where Homer works. There is a story of disenchantment involving
incest, violence and disagreement about the way of life there. The film
is ideal at examining the reality that people from "the greatest
generation" were the same as people today in terms of personal
behaviour, and in the film industry recently, we have had a number of
examples that show that times change but people don't. The film is
directed by Lasse Hallstrom, the Swedish director responsible for such
films as 'My Life as a Dog', 'Once Around' and 'What's Eating Gilbert
Grape?', a movie with a curious tie-in to this film about a young man
coming of age and seeing the world in more realistic terms than he's
been used to. The film is also written by John Irving, based on his
novel and his screenplay is without pretentious qualities,
sentimentality or cliches. As for the cast, there are many things you
can say. I look back to 1987's 'The Untouchables' and my father and I
still have a debate over the way Kevin Costner played Elliot Ness. My
father called it a "wet wash cloth performance" while I was impressed
by it. The whole point of the film was to draw wisdom from a more
experienced character, that of Jimmy Malone (Sean Connery). That's the
way I saw 'The Cider House Rules' play out. Tobey Maguire's character
of Homer is rather toned done but Maguire draws his experience in life
from those more experienced and becomes a better man for it, especially
when he finds out at the end what Dr. Larch does for him. Charlize
Theron, Delroy Lindo, along with Jane Alexander and Kathy Baker who
plays nurses at the clinic are characters who aren't really given a
deep sense of focus as much as they should be but their contributions
to the film and still significant. Michael Caine is the real treat of
this film, giving his best performance since his Oscar win in 1986 for
best supporting actor in 'Hannah and Her Sisters'. Caine won rave
reviews in 1998 as a third string English talent agent in 'Little
Voice' and while winning a Golden Globe for it, he was snubbed by the
Oscars and didn't even get nominated for the role. 'The Cider House
Rules' may bring Caine another Oscar win as he was sort of the surprise
winner in 1986 and Caine's clever talent as an actor is matched by his
willingness to diversify himself and he is one of the best at it. Visit
FILM FOLLOW-UP by Walter Frith
Do you know something we don't?
Submit a correction or make a comment about this profile
Copyright ©2019 Soylent Communications
|
